6 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Frankie Evans's avatar

if you do not have the electoral college 8 states would determine the outcome of the presidency in the US every 4 years (Ca, NY, PA, FL, TX, Ill, Oh, GA) the states identified consist of 150 mil people. Therefore you would not have a republic and no plurality. Removing 25% from the 150 mil takes the voting age citizenry to 112.5 mil, removal of 25% of the voting age population from each state is the average when it comes to total population. Total voting age citizenry out of 335 mil people in the US minus 25% = 251 mil voting age citizens, during the most recent presidential election approximately 155 mil people voted, which is plurality whether we like it or not, which coincides with the electoral count. If we go to one man one vote we will not have plurality. Personally I support the electoral college, which gives states with a very low population a voice in the political process, which we could argue at this point is corrupted.

Expand full comment
Maximina Juson's avatar

Hi Frankie,

Thank you for your comment. To be candid, I do find it remarkable how much mental gymnastics it takes to argue that the Electoral College is superior to the straightforward principle that every person’s vote should count equally in America. We have a presidential electoral system that most Americans don’t fully understand—one where just a handful of votes in key swing states can change the outcome (even with a variance of millions nationally), creating an environment ripe for manipulation and corruption. States are not people, nor do their residents vote as monolithic blocs. While the Electoral College gives smaller states a slight advantage by granting them two extra electoral votes for their Senate representation, the real imbalance lies elsewhere. Election after election, swing states reap the real benefits—receiving nearly all the attention, the bulk of campaign visits, and over 90% of campaign spending—while voters in reliably red and blue states, regardless of size, are largely ignored.

The Electoral College does not exist because America is a democratic republic, as every other election in the U.S. relies on a simple majority vote by the people. If you’re interested in a deeper exploration of this topic, I encourage you to watch my film, One Person, One Vote?, available on PBS Passport, where I dive into the well-researched history and origins of the Electoral College.

Thanks again for taking the time to share your thoughts!

Expand full comment